Tuesday, December 02, 2008 You are here: Articles > BBC Watch Printer Friendly Page
Register | Login
 Search



BBC Watch
Current  Archive  
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ...
BBC Watch
The BBC: Legitimising mass slaughter in Fallujah
Monday, November 08, 2004 (512 reads)


In 1984, Edward Herman and Frank Brodhead described how "demonstration elections" are "organised and staged by a foreign power primarily to pacify a restive home population, reassuring it that ongoing interventionary processes are legitimate and appreciated by their foreign objects." (Herman and Brodhead, Demonstration Elections, South End Press, 1984, p.5)

In the case of Iraq, it is of course vital that domestic audiences in the US and UK be persuaded that their governments are killing Iraqis with the support of, even on behalf of, Iraqis themselves. The possibility that Iraqis might be dying in their tens of thousands for Western power and profit must, of course, be kept so far out of sight that it is barely even thinkable.


Read More
BBC Watch
AMW comparative media study: Philo & Berry vs Asserson
Thursday, April 28, 2005 (1562 reads)


Arab Media Watch director Judith Brown, who is undertaking a PhD in Imagery of Arabs in the British Media, analyses a report by Trevor Asserson, a London-based solicitor who organised research on BBC output on behalf of BBC Watch.

She also analyses research by Glasgow University's Greg Philo and Mike Berry concerning BBC and ITV presentation of the Middle East conflict, and compares methodology of the two pieces of research.


Read More
BBC Watch
Fallujah: The BBC's director of news responds
Saturday, November 27, 2004 (519 reads)


By Medialens.org

On November 8 and 11 we published two Media Alerts: 'Legitimising Mass Slaughter in Fallujah,' in which we commented on the bias and inhumanity of BBC and ITV News reporting on Fallujah.

These alerts generated a massive response from readers - one of the biggest we have seen - and contributed, we believe, to a short-lived improvement in both BBC and ITV reporting. As a flood of emails was being copied to us, the BBC in particular began paying attention to the plight of civilians in Fallujah in a way that it had conspicuously not done earlier in the week. This could of course have been a coincidence, but we doubt it. We suspect that BBC editors and journalists were shocked by the intensity and extent of public feeling, a suspicion strengthened by a response of unprecedented seriousness from the BBC's director of news, Helen Boaden.


Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Monday, October 11, 2004 (492 reads)


An analysis of the Today programme covering October 4-10 by Arab Media Watch director Judith Brown.

This week there was a marked difference between the reporting of the deaths of Palestinians and Israelis, bigger than in any other week since I started monitoring Today in December 2003.


Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Monday, October 18, 2004 (459 reads)


An analysis of the Today programme covering October 11-17 by Arab Media Watch director Judith Brown.

Appallingly, this week we have simply nothing on Today after the rape of Jabaliya by the Israeli Defence Forces.


Read More
BBC Watch
BBC Today
Thursday, September 30, 2004 (599 reads)


Arab Media Watch director Judith Brown, who is undertaking a PhD in "Imagery of Arabs in the British Media", describes her July-September 2004 analysis of BBC Radio 4's flagship programme as "damning".



Read More
BBC Watch
AMW media interview: BBC reporting doesn't tell whole story
Tuesday, April 05, 2005 (1078 reads)


Tim Llewellyn was the BBC's Middle East correspondent twice from 1976-1982 and 1987-1992. Based in Beirut and Cyprus, Llewellyn covered the Lebanese civil war, the Iranian Revolution, the Tanker Wars, the first Palestinian intifada, and the first Gulf War. He was one of the first foreign correspondents to enter the camps of Sabra and Shatila after the massacres there by Phalangist Forces under the auspices of the Israeli army in September 1982.

In this interview with Arab Media Watch director Victor Kattan, Llewellyn talks candidly about the BBC, and the pressures that organisation and its correspondents are under, when reporting from the Middle East.


Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Thursday, November 04, 2004 (490 reads)


An analysis of the Today programme covering October 25-31 by Arab Media Watch director Judith Brown.



The total dead since the start of the second intifada is 4,540: 3,509 Palestinians, 957 Israelis. This week, the IDF killed 4 Palestinian militants, 2 Palestinian security officers, 4 Palestinian children, and 13 of unknown status.



Lots of news this week from all perspectives, following the disengagement vote in the Knesset (Israel's Parliament) and the illness of Palestinian President Yasser Arafat. Some balanced interviews with Arab spokespersons.


Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Monday, September 06, 2004 (488 reads)


An analysis of the Today programme covering August 30 to September 5 by Arab Media Watch director Judith Brown.



Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Thursday, September 02, 2004 (449 reads)


An analysis of the Today programme covering August 23-29 by Arab Media Watch director Judith Brown.

Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Monday, August 23, 2004 (465 reads)


An analysis of the Today programme covering August 16-22 by Arab Media Watch director Judith Brown.

This week there were 15 Palestinians killed by the IDF, making a total of 4,245 killed since the intifada started - 3,247 Palestinians and 927 Israelis. The breakdown is 9 militants, 3 civilians, 1 of unknown status, 2 children. A Palestinian was killed in an explosion in Ramallah, an IDF spokesman said it may have been someone making an explosive device. None of these deaths were mentioned on "Today" - from the comments on the death of Sheikh Yassin last week, it is obvious Palestinian dead aren't worthy of a name, but more tragically, Palestinian deaths aren't even numbers on BBC radio and haven't been for some time.



Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Monday, August 16, 2004 (491 reads)


An analysis of the Today programme covering August 9-15 by AMW director Judith Brown.

Read More
BBC Watch
Comments on the BBC watch Documentary Campaign
Thursday, August 12, 2004 (529 reads)


Arab Media Watch director Judith Brown, who is undertaking a PhD in "The Image of Arabs in the British Media", critiques a pro-Israel report on BBC documentaries published on BBCwatch.com

Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Wednesday, August 11, 2004 (483 reads)


An analysis of the Today programme covering August 2 - 9 by AMW director Judith Brown.

'Today' reporting on the Middle East has returned to the system of clips early in the morning when there are few listeners, and not using spokesmen from either side. The BBC reports on an Israeli agenda and does not reflect Palestinian concerns. This system may be designed to prevent harassment of the BBC by supporters of Palestinians and Israelis (this is a real problem for media organisations), but it has the effect of hiding Palestinian suffering.


Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Monday, August 02, 2004 (650 reads)


An analysis of the Today programme covering July 26 - August 1 by AMW director Judith Brown.

Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Monday, September 27, 2004 (475 reads)


An analysis of the Today programme covering September 20-26 by Arab Media Watch director Judith Brown.

Read More
BBC Watch
AMW 3-month analysis of BBC Radio 4 Today programme
Sunday, February 13, 2005 (1286 reads)


"Individual BBC correspondents are more likely to report the Israeli perspective in the conflict," concludes Arab Media Watch director Judith Brown in an in-depth study of BBC Radio 4's flagship programme during July, August and September 2004.

Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Wednesday, October 27, 2004 (492 reads)


An analysis of the Today programme covering October 18-24 by Arab Media Watch director Judith Brown.


Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Tuesday, October 05, 2004 (486 reads)


An analysis of the Today programme covering September 27 to October 3 by Arab Media Watch director Judith Brown.

Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Monday, September 20, 2004 (450 reads)


An analysis of the Today programme covering September 13-19 by Arab Media Watch director Judith Brown.

Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Monday, September 13, 2004 (483 reads)


An analysis of the Today programme covering September 6-12 by Arab Media Watch director Judith Brown.

Read More
BBC Watch
The BBC: Occupation? What occupation?!
Thursday, July 29, 2004 (507 reads)


By AMW chairman Sharif Hikmat Nashashibi

What prompted me to write this article was an item on the BBC website that exemplified all that is fundamentally wrong with the corporation's coverage of the Arab-Israeli conflict.


Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Monday, July 26, 2004 (443 reads)


An analysis of the Today programme covering July 19-25 by Judith Brown, a director of Arab Media Watch.

Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Monday, July 19, 2004 (488 reads)


An analysis of the Today programme covering July 12-18 by Judith Brown, a director of Arab Media Watch.

Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Monday, May 31, 2004 (466 reads)


An analysis covering May 24-30 by Judith Brown, a director of Arab Media Watch.

Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Monday, May 17, 2004 (453 reads)


An analysis covering May 10-16 by Judith Brown, a director of Arab Media Watch.

Still a culture among the whole British media of ignoring the terrible situation in which Palestinians have to live. The destruction of what little is left in Gaza goes on, and on, and on - silently. This lack of interest is utterly and completely shocking and hard to understand, as apart from the human rights of Palestinians, in this current political climate the humiliation of Palestinians is strongly associated with our own economic fortunes and future security. The row over US torture, the fate of ex-Mirror editor Piers Morgan and speculation about Tony Blair's future are being used by Israel to 'bury' its inhumane and illegal behaviour.


Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Monday, May 10, 2004 (469 reads)


An analysis covering May 3-9 by Judith Brown, a director of Arab Media Watch.

Note the list at the end of what is NOT being reported is getting longer each week. There are the continuous dribble of killings, 15 this week taking the total to 3,000 PALESTINIANS KILLED since the start of this intifada, with 905 Israelis killed in the same period.

The ethnic cleansing is getting extremely worrying. Note this week the number of house demolitions, land seizures and new settlement activity (including illegal settlement funding from the Israeli government) - reports accelerate all the time. In Rafah alone an UNRWA report released this week says over 11,000 people have had their homes demolished since 2000.

Another inhumane act - Israeli Arabs cannot visit their families in Gaza unless they stay for 3 months. This also smacks of an attempt at ethnic cleansing of Palestinian Arabs from Israel. Israeli Transport Minister Avigor Leiberman has proposed ethnically cleansing the 1.3 million Arab citizens of Israel, and Sharon refused to condemn his statement.

Nothing on the hundreds of people in Gaza denied medical treatment. And a new barrier is going up around the settlements in Gaza that Sharon was planning to dismantle - also ignored. Very little is said on the US ambassadors' letter, and nothing on the UN General Assembly resolution stating that Palestinians have sovereignty over the West Bank and Gaza Strip.

Meanwhile Bush drops the Road Map for the foreseeable future - Palestinians protest but who listens to them? Not the BBC. Nothing on the protest against Israeli actions by 212 European NGOs, nothing on the strange gas attacks in Jayyous village by the Israeli army causing abortions and their desperate plea for the world to help them.

The world is rightly shocked at the humiliation of Iraqis, but what has to happen before the BBC and other media outlets report the horrendous humiliation that is the everyday lot of all Palestinians living under occupation - and why do we never see anything on Israeli war crimes in the British media?


Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Monday, April 19, 2004 (543 reads)


An analysis covering April 12-18 by Judith Brown, a director of Arab Media Watch.

Interestingly, while usually the Iraq coverage has hidden Israeli persecution of Palestinians, this week the opposite happened. Since Sharon has been given everything he wants by Bush, and also assassinated al-Rantisi, the world has forgotten about the massacre by US troops of 700 people, mostly ordinary Iraqi citizens in Fallujah. The debate ceased simply because of the wide media coverage of Israeli actions and policies. There has been more news on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict reported this week than in any other since I started monitoring in December 2003.


Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Monday, April 12, 2004 (456 reads)


An analysis covering April 5-11 by Judith Brown, a director of Arab Media Watch.


Only 'Today' programme monitored this week.

'Today' programme Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Friday - no reports.



Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Tuesday, April 06, 2004 (485 reads)


An analysis covering March 28-April 4 by Judith Brown, a member of AMW's executive committee.


Read More
BBC Watch
3-month AMW analysis of BBC 'Today' programme
Thursday, March 11, 2004 (503 reads)


An analysis covering December 1 to February 29 by Judith Brown, a member of Arab Media Watch's executive committee who is undertaking a PhD in "Imagery of Arabs in the British Media".

Read More
BBC Watch
The BBC and the quiet ethnic cleansing of Palestinians
Thursday, February 12, 2004 (484 reads)


By Paul de Rooij
February 12, 2004

At present, ethnic cleansing of Palestinians is ongoing and systematic, yet it is difficult to find any reference to this crime against humanity in most news media. The issue is not so much slanted coverage as scant or selective coverage of the misery Israel is inflicting on the Palestinians. Although the BBC has a reputation for fair and balanced reporting, when it comes to Israel-Palestine a different standard seems to be applied, as even gross violations of human rights are not reported.


Read More
BBC Watch
BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine: December 22-28
Friday, January 02, 2004 (472 reads)


A summary by Judith Brown, a member of Arab Media Watch's executive committee.

Read More
BBC Watch
Summary of trends in BBC coverage of Israel/Palestine
Monday, December 15, 2003 (525 reads)


An Arab Media Watch summary of trends in the BBC's online and radio coverage of Israel/Palestine, covering December 2-14.

Read More
BBC Watch
Summary of trends in BBC online coverage November 24-30
Wednesday, December 03, 2003 (500 reads)


This is the second of periodic Arab Media Watch summaries highlighting trends in the BBC's online Middle East coverage. With the recent appointment of Malcolm Balen to oversee such coverage, it is vital to understand how the BBC reports the news, and keep Balen and relevant others informed of the facts and your views.

Read More
BBC Watch
BBC Watch - October 8, 2003
Wednesday, October 08, 2003 (519 reads)


Decent online coverage of Iraq overall, poor coverage of the Arab-Israeli conflict, where again Israeli and US views are given more prominence than Syria's. In general, the BBC missed a lot of important news.

Read More
BBC Watch
BBC Watch - October 7, 2003
Tuesday, October 07, 2003 (504 reads)


BBC Online continues to give Israeli versions of events greater prevalence than those of Lebanon and Syria, and the illegal occupation of the Palestinian territories is not mentioned at all - in fact, correspondent James Reynolds implies that Jerusalem is Israel's capital!

Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Monday, February 16, 2004 (446 reads)


An analysis covering February 9-15 by Judith Brown, a member of Arab Media Watch's executive committee.


Some quite amazing omissions on 'Today' programme this week.


Read More
BBC Watch
BBC Watch - October 6, 2003
Monday, October 06, 2003 (524 reads)


Trouble in Syria, Palestine, Iraq and Lebanon. Unfortunately, the BBC's online coverage (or lack of in the case of Iraq) leaves much to be desired.

The same cannot be said of its TV programme Hard Talk, with guest Scott Ritter, former UN weapons inspector in Iraq, providing thorough, technical and accurate rebuttals to US/UK government propaganda. This was one of the few Hard Talk shows where the interview was not dominated by the interviewer.


Read More
BBC Watch
BBC Watch - October 5, 2003
Sunday, October 05, 2003 (494 reads)


A patchy day for BBC Online regarding Israel's attack against Syria and threats against Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat. Coverage of those developments overshadows events in Iraq, where the BBC misses some important news.

Read More
BBC Watch
BBC Watch - October 4, 2003
Saturday, October 04, 2003 (522 reads)


Not a bad day for BBC Online, though again its terminology over Israel's barrier in the occupied West Bank is all over the place.

Read More
BBC Watch
BBC Watch - October 3, 2003
Friday, October 03, 2003 (488 reads)


Generally good online coverage today, mostly on Iraq, though the BBC missed out several important developments in Israel/Palestine.

Read More
BBC Watch
Arabic BBC channel regarded with skepticism in Middle East
Friday, July 16, 2004 (512 reads)


By Paul Cochrane
Daily Star (Lebanon)

The BBC announced last month that it intends to set up an Arabic television station backed by the British Foreign and Commonwealth Office (FCO) with a $50 million a year budget. This has been met with skepticism in the Middle East, coming so soon after the US-led war on Iraq, and hot on the heels of a US-government backed Arabic channel.

The BBC channel was requested by the FCO, a BBC spokesperson said, and would be based out of London, broadcasting 24 hours a day across the Arab world. The BBC added that the proposal was still under discussion between the FCO and the British Treasury, and a start up date had not been established.

The BBC has attempted to break into the Arab television market before, running an aborted attempt in the early 1990s that closed down after backers pulled out.

"It was a lot friendlier climate back then and I think now they're going to have a much tougher time," said Sharif Hikmat Nashashibi, chairman of the London-based Arab Media Watch in a telephone interview with The Daily Star.

"They didn't have the Arab competition they have now, and the political climate, in my view, is rightly hostile towards UK and US policy, and the BBC might be associated with that," he added.


Read More
BBC Watch
AMW summary of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Tuesday, December 23, 2003 (503 reads)


A summary covering the week of December 15-21, compiled by Judith Brown, a member of Arab Media Watch's executive committee.

Read More
BBC Watch
BBC Watch - October 2, 2003
Thursday, October 02, 2003 (467 reads)


A fair bit of online coverage of Israel/Palestine and Iraq - some good, most not so good.

Radio 4 coverage was much better, with an excellent Today programme featuring Dr. Glen Rangwala and Dr. Riad Al-Taher discussing Iraq's alleged weapons of mass destruction, and an equally good programme entitled "It's my story", about Neta Golan, who was a staunch supporter of Israel but then founded an international protest movement against the occupation of the West Bank and Gaza.


Read More
BBC Watch
BBC Watch - September 30, 2003
Wednesday, October 01, 2003 (462 reads)


A mixed bag concerning the BBC's coverage of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.


Read More
BBC Watch
Critical letter to head of BBC news from former Middle East correspondent
Thursday, September 11, 2003 (653 reads)


A critical letter from Tim Llewellyn to Richard Sambrook, managing editor of BBC News and Current Affairs:

Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Thursday, July 15, 2004 (449 reads)


An analysis covering July 1-11 by Judith Brown, a director of Arab Media Watch.

Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Sunday, March 14, 2004 (485 reads)


An analysis covering March 8-13 by Judith Brown, a member of AMW's executive committee.



Read More
BBC Watch
BBC Watch - October 10, 2003
Saturday, October 11, 2003 (495 reads)


A mixed bag for BBC Online today, and it has again missed out important news, particularly on Iraq and Palestine.

The Daily Telegraph's claim on October 7 that the BBC website almost always puts the terms terrorists and terrorism in quote marks when it comes to Arabs is exposed, yet again, as utter nonsense.


Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Monday, May 24, 2004 (472 reads)


An analysis covering May 17-23 by Judith Brown, a director of Arab Media Watch.

Due to the appalling, illegal and reckless behaviour of Israel and world condemnation the BBC reported a lot of news from Gaza this week, although my opinion is that it was not given the prominence it deserved. On one occasion a BBC reporter actually BLAMED the Palestinians for being in the place where Israeli tanks fired at them, killing 10 including children and injuring 40. According to the reporter, Palestinian demonstrations in that area were asking for trouble. On another occasion BBC reporter James Reynolds called the Gaza situation 'fascinating' - this is really shocking terminology to use in this situation. The BBC also managed to do the full week's reporting without using the world 'occupation', except on one brief news item when they reported what was said at an Arab League meeting. This is completely irresponsible and can have no possible excuse, as they regularly use the word 'occupation' when it relates to Iraq. This week's terminology really deserves comment, please write to the BBC.

There is no recognition anywhere that home demolition is related to ethnic cleansing, as in many instances the demolition of homes and the confiscation of land are followed by the building of Jewish settlements. This is not the only instance of ethnic cleansing this week - Israel is also trying to deport 3 Palestinians living in the West Bank who were born overseas. Also, although not reported by the BBC, Israel plans to kill 1,000 militants in Gaza before it leaves - these are illegal assassinations and not to raise this issue of further war crimes is irresponsible, bearing in mind the war crimes that have already been committed this week, and also bearing in mind that people living under occupation are allowed armed struggle under international law.


Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Monday, May 03, 2004 (469 reads)


An analysis covering April 26 - May 2 by Judith Brown, a director of Arab Media Watch.

13 Palestinian deaths not reported this week, nor the ethnic cleansing policy in East Jerusalem, where Arab houses are now being demolished - the plan is to demolish 400 in all. Israel appears to be getting more confident in these illegal and immoral policies - but whereas ethnic cleansing gets high media coverage in Kosovo, it is ignored in Palestinian territories and Israel. Meanwhile the deaths of 5 settlers WAS reported. Another appearance by the Israeli ambassador on the 'Today' programme, which never seems to invite the Palestinian representative.

On the positive side, some good documentaries and current affairs items this week and a sympathetic Reith Lecture, as well as a reasonable amount of coverage of the ex-ambassadors' letter criticising Tony Blair's Middle East policies.


Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Monday, April 26, 2004 (466 reads)


An analysis covering April 19-25 by Judith Brown, a director of Arab Media Watch.

This week another serious Israeli incursion into northern Gaza killing amongst others 5 children, omitted totally from BBC Radio 4 news, despite 'serious concerns' expressed by UN Secretary General Kofi Annan. Plus many other deaths in the West Bank, again unreported.


Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Monday, April 12, 2004 (487 reads)


An analysis covering April 5-11 by Judith Brown, a director of Arab Media Watch.


Only 'Today' programme monitored this week.

'Today' programme Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Friday - no reports.



Read More
BBC Watch
BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine: Dec 29-Jan 4
Monday, January 05, 2004 (466 reads)


A summary by Judith Brown, a member of Arab Media Watch's executive committee.

Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Monday, March 08, 2004 (510 reads)


An analysis covering March 1-7 by Judith Brown, a member of AMW's executive committee.


This week on the 5th and 6th there are two very good items on Islamophobia, although one was not named as such. Write and thank the BBC as we need more programmes on this very important subject. Anti-Semitism is currently not causing nearly as many problems but it is prominent on the BBC, including the Moral Maze this week.



Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Monday, March 01, 2004 (645 reads)


An analysis covering February 23-29 by Judith Brown, a member of AMW's executive committee.


BBC radio has now been monitored for 3 months and shortly there will be a full analysis of the monitoring during this period.

I accidentally omitted one item from BBC monitoring last week.


Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Tuesday, March 23, 2004 (489 reads)


An analysis covering February 16-22 by Judith Brown, a member of AMW's executive committee.


Read More
BBC Watch
AMW analysis of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Monday, February 09, 2004 (487 reads)


An analysis covering February 2-8 by Judith Brown, a member of Arab Media Watch's executive committee.


Read More
BBC Watch
AMW summary of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Monday, February 02, 2004 (465 reads)


A summary covering the period January 26 to February 1, compiled by Judith Brown, a member of Arab Media Watch's executive committee.


Since my analysis of Middle East-related coverage on BBC Radio 4 started on December 2, this has been the most appalling week, with serious omissions, distorted coverage of the news and no mention of the word "occupation", which has not been used for two months.


Read More
BBC Watch
AMW summary of BBC Radio 4 coverage of Israel/Palestine
Thursday, January 29, 2004 (487 reads)


A summary covering January 5-25 by Judith Brown, a member of AMW's executive committee.


During this period the Today programme was the only programme monitored between January 5-21.

From January 5-10 there were no reports on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, except for a newspaper review from Jerusalem on January 9. No spokesmen. Note: when there is a news review they often look at Jerusalem papers but when they do so, they review the Jewish press but not the Arabic press.


Read More
BBC Watch
BBC Watch - September 29, 2003
Monday, September 29, 2003 (490 reads)


Today marks the birth of Arab Media Watch's daily BBC Watch, compelled by the Daily Telegraph's "Beeb Watch" regarding perceived bias against Israel and the US/UK occupation of Iraq.

Through our lengthy monitoring of BBC News Online, we decided it was time to let you, the public, judge for yourself.


Read More
BBC Watch
Critical letter to BBC by former Middle East correspondent
Friday, August 22, 2003 (541 reads)


A letter by Tim Llewellyn to BBC head Richard Sambrook and Today editor Kevin Marsh.

Read More
BBC Watch
Boost for BBC's Arabic service
Wednesday, October 10, 2007 (475 reads)


By Bob Fenton
10 October 2007
Financial Times

The BBC World Service will receive above-inflation funding from the Foreign Office over three years to expand television services beamed to the Arabic-speaking world and begin new broadcasts to Iran and Afghanistan.



Read More
BBC Watch
AMW Monitoring Study: BBC Coverage of the Israel-Palestine Conflict
Sunday, January 01, 2006 (1255 reads)


AMW has produced a major report into the BBC's coverage of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, revealing significant, persistent and worrying imbalances that have been highlighted in previous studies undertaken by AMW and others.

The report is a response to an invitation by the BBC for AMW to submit its views on the topic, as part of an impartiality review by the corporation. We not only compared coverage across a wide range of BBC outlets, but also to Agence France Presse, Aljazeera and Reuters. The report covers a one-month period of mid-October to mid-November 2005.

It is available at: AMW_Monitoring_Summary_Of_BBC_Coverage.pdf (168Kb)



Read More
BBC Watch
No plan, no peace and no responsibility
Wednesday, October 31, 2007 (366 reads)


By Mary Dejevsky
31 October 2007
The Independent

Whenever the BBC comes under financial pressure, the Director-General reaches for the hoary old threat of back-to-back repeats. In so doing, however, he does the Corporation a disservice. There are programmes that warrant an almost instant re-showing and regular outings thereafter. One such is John Ware's two-part documentary about the aftermath of the invasion of Iraq, No Plan, No Peace, which went out this Sunday and Monday.

Invariably, the very programmes that deserve to be repeated seem to be the ones allowed to languish in the bowels of Television Centre until such time as they are pronounced "classics". To judge by the BBC's response when I tried to find more about Ware's documentary yesterday, this is the fate in store for No Plan, No Peace.



Read More
BBC Watch
Comparative BBC analysis: AMW, independent panel, Loughborough & Lubell reports
Monday, May 15, 2006 (5051 reads)


In 2005, the BBC decided to undertake an impartiality review of its coverage of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. As such, it commissioned an independent panel, the Communications Research Centre at Loughborough University, and British-Israeli international lawyer Noam Lubell. The BBC also invited a number of organisations, including Arab Media Watch (which analysed a 1-month period in the form of a 47-page report), to submit their views.

An AMW delegation (including Sharif Hikmat Nashashibi, Victor Kattan, Muna Nashashibi and Maha Abdullahad) met with the independent panel in January 2006.

The findings of the panel, Loughborough and Lubell were published in April 2006, and corroborate extensively those of AMW. Following are comparative extracts from the panel's report and that of AMW, with the latter in bold:



Read More
BBC Watch
BBC plans dramas on run-up to Iraq war
Friday, January 25, 2008 (270 reads)


By Owen Gibson, media correspondent
25 January 2008
The Guardian

The BBC is planning a controversial dramatisation of the run-up to the war in Iraq, to be broadcast over 10 days in March, ahead of the fifth anniversary of the start of the conflict.

Starring Kenneth Branagh as Colonel Tim Collins, as well as Art Malik and Harriet Walter, the high profile series will focus on the events that happened on the corresponding days five years earlier, the BBC said yesterday.

The series, overseen by Colin Barr, who made an acclaimed drama-documentary about Robert Maxwell, will tell the story of the hunt for weapons of mass destruction, the debates in the UN, the plans for reconstruction and the countdown to the war, which began on the night of March 20 2003.



Read More
BBC Watch
BBC Arabic to launch TV news channel
Monday, March 03, 2008 (1564 reads)


BBC Arabic Television - the BBC's news and information channel in the Arabic language - launches on Tuesday March 11 at 10.00hrs GMT, it was announced today (Monday 3 March 2008).

Initially broadcast for 12 hours a day, the television channel is part of the BBC's integrated multi-media news service for the Arab world. It will move to 24/7 in the summer and is the BBC's first publicly funded international television service.



Read More
BBC Watch
BBC Arabic seeks UK-based Arabic-speaking students
Friday, March 07, 2008 (2056 reads)


Your role will include:

- Receive calls in the call centre during leading phone-in programmes for radio and TV
- Archiving
- Perform ad-hoc jobs such as welcoming and receiving guests in reception and guiding them to studios

Requirements:

- Arabic as a mother tongue or equivalent
- Good verbal communication skills in Arabic and English
- Ability to speak and understand major Arabic dialects
- Comfortable using computers
- Valid UK work permit

Duration:

- 3 hours a day, 3 days a week for an ongoing basis



Read More
BBC Watch
Acts of War: The stories behind the invasion of Iraq
Monday, March 10, 2008 (1480 reads)


By Ian Burrell
10 March 2008
The Independent

Given the pain suffered by the BBC over its previous attempts to decipher the events that led to the invasion of Iraq, some might be surprised by its plans to produce a series of dramatic reconstructions of some of the critical stories in the days prior to the war.

Yet Newsnight viewers remain so fascinated and exercised by this period that the writer Ronan Bennett was hired to make 10 Days to War, a series of eight short films that will attempt – through the medium of drama – to enhance understanding of what actually went on.



Read More
BBC Watch
BBC Arabic TV service tunes in to crowded news market
Thursday, March 06, 2008 (583 reads)


By Adam Sherwin
6 March 2008
The Times

The last time that the BBC tried to launch an Arabic television channel, in 1996, it collapsed. Its partners in Saudi Arabia pulled out of the commercially funded channel over a Panorama report on human rights abuses in the Kingdom. In the wake of the debacle, several employees went on to found al-Jazeera.

More than a decade on and al-Jazeera is an established voice in the region, yet the BBC believes that there is room for its "authoritative and impartial" Arabic-language service to be launched into a crowded media marketplace on Monday.



Read More
BBC Watch
Covering Israel-Palestine: The BBC's double standards
Tuesday, April 22, 2008 (1496 reads)


Medialens takes part in an exchange with the BBC's Middle East editor Jeremy Bowen.

22 April 2008



Read More
BBC Watch
A murderous theater of the absurd
Thursday, September 11, 2008 (1191 reads)


By John Pilger
11 September 2008

Try to laugh, please. The news is now officially parody and a game for all the family to play.

First question: Why are "we" in Afghanistan? Answer: "To try to help in the country's rebuilding program." Who says so? Huw Edwards, the BBC's principal newsreader. What wags the Welsh are.

Second question: Why are "we" in Iraq? Answer: To "plant a western-style open democracy." Who says so? Paul Wood, the former BBC defense correspondent, and his boss Helen Boaden, director of BBC News. To prove her point, Boaden supplied Medialens.org with 2,700 words of quotations from Tony Blair and George W Bush. Irony? No, she meant it.

Take Andrew Martin, divisional adviser at BBC Complaints, who has been researching Bush's speeches for "evidence" of noble democratic reasons for laying to waste an ancient civilization. Says he: "The 'D' word is not there, but the phrase 'united, stable and free' [is] clearly an allusion to it." After all, he says, the invasion of Iraq "was launched as 'Operation Iraqi Freedom'." Moreover,20says the BBC man, "in Bush's 1 May 2003 speech (the one on the aircraft carrier) he talked repeatedly about freedom and explicitly about the Iraqi transition to democracy ... These examples show that these were on Bush's mind before, during and after the invasion."

Try to laugh, please.



Read More
BBC Watch
BBC accused of censorship after cancelling short story broadcast
Tuesday, April 17, 2007 (438 reads)


Owen Gibson, media correspondent
17 April 2007
The Guardian

The author Hanif Kureishi accused the BBC of censorship last night, after it dropped a radio broadcast of his short story describing the work of a cameraman who films the executions of western captives in Iraq.



Read More
BBC Watch
Britain enlists Palestinian firebrand to free BBC reporter
Thursday, May 17, 2007 (456 reads)


Agence France Presse
17 May 2007

LONDON - The British government said Thursday it is asking a Palestinian cleric detained here whether he would be willing to appeal for the release of BBC journalist Alan Johnston from the Gaza Strip.



Read More
BBC Watch
BBC interviewees request
Thursday, June 21, 2007 (584 reads)


21 June 2007

Arab Media Watch has received a BBC request for interviewees on the Middle East.



Read More
BBC Watch
Hamas 'working to free BBC man'
Friday, June 15, 2007 (412 reads)


BBC News
15 June 2007

The Palestinian Islamist movement, Hamas, says it is taking "practical steps" to secure the release of kidnapped BBC reporter Alan Johnston.

Hamas said it had sent a warning to Mr Johnston's kidnappers, hours after the movement claimed victory in a bloody power struggle in Gaza.

A spokesman said Mr Johnston, a hostage for three months, was the Palestinians' guest and should be made welcome.



Read More
BBC Watch
Former US ambassador in on-air spat with 'superior' BBC man
Thursday, May 17, 2007 (540 reads)


Agence France Presse
17 May 2007

LONDON - Straight-talking former US ambassador to the United Nations John Bolton accused a top BBC presenter of being leftwing and "a superior Brit" in a colourful on-air spat Thursday.

The controversial ex-diplomat, who left the UN post in January, made the comments after fiercely defending the United States' role in Iraq and saying that force should be used against Iran if necessary.



Read More
BBC Watch
BBC apologises over Jerusalem
Friday, June 08, 2007 (939 reads)


8 June 2007

The BBC has issued a written apology in response to a joint complaint by Arab Media Watch, the Muslim Public Affairs Committee, Friends of Al Aqsa and the Institute of Islamic Political Thought, after a presenter on BBC 1's Football Focus incorrectly described Jerusalem as Israel's "capital," a well as "its historic soul."



Read More
BBC Watch
AMW concern over BBC documentary 'Will Israel Bomb Iran?'
Monday, February 12, 2007 (805 reads)


12 February 2007

Arab Media Watch is concerned by the 'This World' programme 'Will Israel Bomb Iran?', broadcast on BBC2 on 10 October 2006. Its severe lack of balance manifested itself in the number and range of sources used, the airtime given them, and the numerous unchallenged claims made about the Arab world.



Read More